Performance **** Sound ****
Rachmaninov’s Second is one of his most lyrical works but also one of the largest, lasting an hour or more. Within his own lifetime a tradition of drastic cuts arose, although, as often happens, by destroying its structure this tended to make the music seem more episodic and showy. These days, however, it is more often presented complete, especially in the rash of recent recordings, many by Russian conductors and orchestras. Polyansky’s, at 59:55 in all, is by no means the longest, but at times it feels so. He gets a warmly idiomatic and unforced reading from his orchestra, but one rather lacking in tension and dynamism. It is by no means bad, but it does not match up to the many rival recordings such as Rozhdestvensky’s rich version (at bargain price) or the sweeping emotional Temirkanov, to name only a couple. Polyansky, however, is a choral specialist, and makes an impressive job of the three songs, with their massive orchestral undertow - more so than his current rival, Dutoit, especially as he does not use a Russian chorus
Michael Scott Rohan - Classic CD - November 1998